Right well i'm not going out with Jay so i'm allowed a different opinion than him.
Don't call me selfish it's pathetic i'm arguing for what I see as best for the league not myself.

it simple as this if you don't like the rules the runners give out don't go in it

am happy with any rules that make things easier for the runners
also i like them simple so every one can understand them less argument for every one to deal with

Agree wholeheartedly. What examples have there been that that wouldnt happen definitely? None this season I think and a couple of issues with Shooter players last season? Would doubted2 have allowed those players to go to different teams than the ones they wanted to - maybe in a different division for example? If so they could have played the remaining games in the season there and then joined their number one choice.

I still think the scenario he quoted is a valid one in terms of maintaining league integrity. Ultimately without the integrity of the league what is the point in any of us playing?

Me going out with Jay has nothing to do with it, i was waiting for this "argument", I already said, Jay has overturned some of my ideas, we do not share a brain you know, we do think differently. However he is head league runner and i have to respect what he decides.

If we had stuck to the league runners decision and not complained when something was wrong you wouldn't be in the league this season so stop throwing that rubbish aroind every 5 minutes rick.

you the only ones that moan cause your scared of losing players that the truth of the matter get over with it
it was put the poll so deal with it m8

If he makes a decision that you feel strongly will have a negative affect on the league(like I think scrapping the match completion bonus will) then you should point it out...nothing to do with respect he is just human like the rest of us and doesn't spot everything.

I think stopping players who move playing for 2 fixtures which is a month of any season, plus they would be with a clan for one fixture set you are already saying it is fixture set 4 at the earliest that any player could play for someone else. And even after then you could not play against your old team so you would probably miss at least 1 other game after that. This would hopefully make the amount of moving to a minimum but it allows players the right to change if they really want to which i think would maintain the integrity of the league.

In my opinion as a captain if you do what craig suggested and stopped players moving just because you didn't want them to, i think that brings in the integrity of the league down more as we are speaking about an online pool game not the champions league

If we wanted to make it so that it is only so players could move to get away to another clan as they were not happy, i think a 1 fixture quarentine and then only being allowed to move to div 2 if you are div 1 player and vice versa would work brilliant and would 100% maintain the integrity of the league.

Show me where I said your disagreeing for the sake of it.

I gave up a while back giving opinions on the rules, just get called idiots if its not what you want to hear.

We're not talking about transfers rick and coming from the man who refused to release a player very recently himself your opinions are quite funny.
We release people and get them replaced with better...not about us it's about the league.

That is saying i'm disagreeing for the sake of it alan

Lee, i do not give in easily and Jay will tell you that, I will argue my case until the cows come home, but if he doesnt like my opinion, there is nothing i can do about it as he makes the final decisions

You're saying I should just accept jay's decision or get out of the league jem i'm saying people have to speak up for what they think is right for the league that's all.

I agree mostly with horse10000, not entirely keen on div 1 players only moving to div 2 and vice versa but i can live with it.

No, thats saying you disagree with 99% and thats up to you, doesn't say your just disagreeing for the sake of it.

right mate i get back to on that with be honest about it

It's what it means alan

but it is jay who decides what happens... have your opinion but what you say isnt necessarily going to be what happens. I am just simply saying if you disagree with how jay is doing things so much then you are free to leave the league whenever you want.

Not at all, I think I know what I meant. to disagree just for the sake of it is being argumentative, I meant you disagree with 99% because you believe your right.

Feel free to disagree with me if you think your right

Rick check all my signings when I was vice made 10-15 in a time when we could get players released quite easily.
I put in the effort and signed players that were free agents because that's what I agree with.
Only players I ever approached in teams were when they were arguing with their team and that was just a message to say 'if it doesn't work out you can play for us.'
I argued for the transfer rule to stay the same because there are so many arguments caused by captains trying to persuade players to leave mid-season and we haven't had any of that this season...only reason.
I'm arguing for the bonus points for match completion to stay now because I feel it will absolutely ruin the league by scrapping them as it will make it better in a lot of cases for clans to let games go to default than play them.
No other motives than that.