League Discussion Thread (2)
Viewing forum thread.
Back to Funkypool Clan League Management.
Back to Forum List.
Deleted User
(IP Logged)
(IP Logged)
22:53 Wed 29 Aug 12 (BST) [Link]
Div 1
Snooker Sqaud
Team Angry
Mouses
Uprising
Legend killers
Underdogs(depending if they wanted to be promoted or not)
Div 2
Chips and Gravy
The Sinners
The Mafia
Fighting Eagles
Professionals
Underdogs(depending if they wanted to be promoted or not)
Thats how i see the league(s)(if everyone qualifys and Jay goes with two divisions)
Snooker Sqaud
Team Angry
Mouses
Uprising
Legend killers
Underdogs(depending if they wanted to be promoted or not)
Div 2
Chips and Gravy
The Sinners
The Mafia
Fighting Eagles
Professionals
Underdogs(depending if they wanted to be promoted or not)
Thats how i see the league(s)(if everyone qualifys and Jay goes with two divisions)
22:54 Wed 29 Aug 12 (BST) [Link]
One league would give everyone 10 games to play.
2 divisions would mean 10 games for the division with 6 teams and 8 games for the smaller one.
2 divisions would mean 10 games for the division with 6 teams and 8 games for the smaller one.
Deleted User
(IP Logged)
(IP Logged)
22:54 Wed 29 Aug 12 (BST) [Link]
Would be 5 in the top 6 in the second, that is the way it has always been split with 11 teams
Div 1
Snooker Sqaud
Team Angry
Mouses
Uprising
Legend killers
Underdogs(depending if they wanted to be promoted or not)
Div 2
Chips and Gravy
The Sinners
The Mafia
Fighting Eagles
Professionals
Underdogs(depending if they wanted to be promoted or not)
Thats how i see the league(s)(if everyone qualifys and Jay goes with two divisions)
Snooker Sqaud
Team Angry
Mouses
Uprising
Legend killers
Underdogs(depending if they wanted to be promoted or not)
Div 2
Chips and Gravy
The Sinners
The Mafia
Fighting Eagles
Professionals
Underdogs(depending if they wanted to be promoted or not)
Thats how i see the league(s)(if everyone qualifys and Jay goes with two divisions)
Would be 5 in the top 6 in the second, that is the way it has always been split with 11 teams
Deleted User
(IP Logged)
(IP Logged)
22:55 Wed 29 Aug 12 (BST) [Link]
I would personally give the underdogs the choice of what division they would want to be in next season with all these new clans that have formed
Deleted User
(IP Logged)
(IP Logged)
23:02 Wed 29 Aug 12 (BST) [Link]
Would rather play the best teams twice, only takes the best new teams staying together through next season for that to happen and get an even split.
That way an experienced enough player who fancied running a clan could just get some inexperienced players together and form another clan to go into the second division and start building something.
Sure the professionals and whoever else goes up will want a crack at you guys the next season.
One league would give everyone 10 games to play.
2 divisions would mean 10 games for the division with 6 teams and 8 games for the smaller one.
2 divisions would mean 10 games for the division with 6 teams and 8 games for the smaller one.
Would rather play the best teams twice, only takes the best new teams staying together through next season for that to happen and get an even split.
That way an experienced enough player who fancied running a clan could just get some inexperienced players together and form another clan to go into the second division and start building something.
Sure the professionals and whoever else goes up will want a crack at you guys the next season.
23:05 Wed 29 Aug 12 (BST) [Link]
This scenario is a good example of why 2 divisions isn't really good.
Look at this season where yet again, loads of div1 teams are folding. So teams are promoted by default. All they have to do is not fold and they'll get into div 1... 2 divisions are no incentive at all to remain a stable clan (that's unfortunately only true in theory).
Look at this season where yet again, loads of div1 teams are folding. So teams are promoted by default. All they have to do is not fold and they'll get into div 1... 2 divisions are no incentive at all to remain a stable clan (that's unfortunately only true in theory).
23:08 Wed 29 Aug 12 (BST) [Link]
i will vote no because it will be even longer between season i dont see y we have to mess with summert thats working well ino we will lose loads of teams this season but most have been made to replace those teams soo i say stick to what it is
23:09 Wed 29 Aug 12 (BST) [Link] Why? It will be exactly the same length with everyone having 10 games. No extra delays
it will be even longer between season
23:10 Wed 29 Aug 12 (BST) [Link]
its just been better like this in my opinion
23:11 Wed 29 Aug 12 (BST) [Link]
That's cool, just didn't want misconceptions about timing.
Deleted User
(IP Logged)
(IP Logged)
23:11 Wed 29 Aug 12 (BST) [Link]
So you want to...
reward the clan that folded mid-season
reward the clans that have folded and formed new ones
take away the promotion that teams have earnt (only 1 second division clan folded that would have gone up)
That won't solve the problem in reality or theory, obviously will have the affect that Alan and I think.
Good example of why 2 divisions isn't really good though.
Look at this season where yet again, loads of div1 teams are folding. So teams are promoted by default. All they have to do is not fold and they'll get into div 1... 2 divisions are no incentive at all to remain a stable clan (that's unfortunately only true in theory).
Look at this season where yet again, loads of div1 teams are folding. So teams are promoted by default. All they have to do is not fold and they'll get into div 1... 2 divisions are no incentive at all to remain a stable clan (that's unfortunately only true in theory).
So you want to...
reward the clan that folded mid-season
reward the clans that have folded and formed new ones
take away the promotion that teams have earnt (only 1 second division clan folded that would have gone up)
That won't solve the problem in reality or theory, obviously will have the affect that Alan and I think.
23:12 Wed 29 Aug 12 (BST) [Link]
23:15 Wed 29 Aug 12 (BST) [Link]
The whole point is that we can't solve the problem of clans folding. They'll fold no matter whether we have 1 division or 2. All the things 2 divisions should prevent have been shown to be only theory!
But the effects aren't as bad with 1 division. For example in div 1 this season, we were left with 4 teams - a total of 6 games in the entire season lol. Bit of a joke.
It wouldn't have been nearly as bad with one large division- we would've been stuck with 9 games instead of 10.
Mouseketeers came third in div 2; Legend Killers 4th. In previous seasons the same was the case with other teams- they often don't "earn" promotion. They are handed it by default for staying alive.
But the effects aren't as bad with 1 division. For example in div 1 this season, we were left with 4 teams - a total of 6 games in the entire season lol. Bit of a joke.
It wouldn't have been nearly as bad with one large division- we would've been stuck with 9 games instead of 10.
Mouseketeers came third in div 2; Legend Killers 4th. In previous seasons the same was the case with other teams- they often don't "earn" promotion. They are handed it by default for staying alive.
Deleted User
(IP Logged)
(IP Logged)
23:19 Wed 29 Aug 12 (BST) [Link]
Pointless discussion! The game will never be changed! Always suited to the best teams! goodnight!
23:26 Wed 29 Aug 12 (BST) [Link]
Its not pointless infact more seem in favour and as how I feel it should be ran if the majority want it thy get it but I feel you need to get more opinions then 10 :)
Btw I control all mouse votes ;) was in the small print of the contract
Pointless discussion! The game will never be changed! Always suited to the best teams! goodnight!
Its not pointless infact more seem in favour and as how I feel it should be ran if the majority want it thy get it but I feel you need to get more opinions then 10 :)
Btw I control all mouse votes ;) was in the small print of the contract
23:28 Wed 29 Aug 12 (BST) [Link]
well im v cap soo i get a say plus u cant stop me soo ner nerr
Deleted User
(IP Logged)
(IP Logged)
23:37 Wed 29 Aug 12 (BST) [Link]
You always spend all season moaning that you have too many games anyway lol
Of course it is a bigger success to keep your clan together than to win the league once with a team of mercenaries
You won't get any teams that stay together at all if you bring in 1 league because what would be the point in staying together and finishing 4th or 5th each season while all the top 15 players on the rankings join together again to make the title winning side for that season.
How many teams that are doing crap would just fold too?
Plus the fact that the league wouldnt even be fair, we play a team in the first fortnight they will be a totally different team for whoever plays them a month and a half later in the last set.
The whole point is that we can't solve the problem of clans folding. They'll fold no matter whether we have 1 division or 2. All the things 2 divisions should prevent have been shown to be only theory!
But the effects aren't as bad with 1 division. For example in div 1 this season, we were left with 4 teams - a total of 6 games in the entire season lol. Bit of a joke.
It wouldn't have been nearly as bad with one large division- we would've been stuck with 9 games instead of 10.
Mouseketeers came third in div 2; Legend Killers 4th. In previous seasons the same was the case with other teams- they often don't "earn" promotion. They are handed it by default for staying alive.
But the effects aren't as bad with 1 division. For example in div 1 this season, we were left with 4 teams - a total of 6 games in the entire season lol. Bit of a joke.
It wouldn't have been nearly as bad with one large division- we would've been stuck with 9 games instead of 10.
Mouseketeers came third in div 2; Legend Killers 4th. In previous seasons the same was the case with other teams- they often don't "earn" promotion. They are handed it by default for staying alive.
You always spend all season moaning that you have too many games anyway lol
Of course it is a bigger success to keep your clan together than to win the league once with a team of mercenaries
You won't get any teams that stay together at all if you bring in 1 league because what would be the point in staying together and finishing 4th or 5th each season while all the top 15 players on the rankings join together again to make the title winning side for that season.
How many teams that are doing crap would just fold too?
Plus the fact that the league wouldnt even be fair, we play a team in the first fortnight they will be a totally different team for whoever plays them a month and a half later in the last set.
23:43 Wed 29 Aug 12 (BST) [Link]
But we said the same thing LOL
well im v cap soo i get a say plus u cant stop me soo ner nerr
But we said the same thing LOL
Deleted User
(IP Logged)
(IP Logged)
23:53 Wed 29 Aug 12 (BST) [Link]
i'll be honest, i don't care if we have 1, 2 or 76 divisions next season. not everyone's ever going to agree over anything, so its pointless 'discussing' it on here, because its all just bickering and arguing. quite a few people have had their chance to put their opinions across, and its going nowhere.
the runners will have read these posts soon, and i'm sure they'll take whats been said into account, but i think we should leave it to them, after all its their free time and effort that's making all this happen
the runners will have read these posts soon, and i'm sure they'll take whats been said into account, but i think we should leave it to them, after all its their free time and effort that's making all this happen
Unable to post | |
---|---|
Reason: | You must log in before you can post |
League Discussion Thread (2)
Back to Top of this Page
Back to Funkypool Clan League Management.
Back to Forum List.