I have done that james its on my docs now

ur first 3 suggestions only ask if a player wants to play, what would be fine is

"you can sub in if u wish" or "i give permission for anyone to sub in for this game"....no one has had a problem with this until now, until a time where no permission was given...

sub ineligible due to no permission given...dont see what the argument is personally

so "you can sub in" and "can you sub in" are a massive difference. To quote John McEnroe- "You can not be serious?"

course it is, ones a question askin if they can sub in, one is actually givin permission...

Was explained yesterday too why we need this rule...



If that situation had happened in this instance latin legends wouldn't be able to get the game replayed as they posted permission for red4ever to sub in....league is covered by that post so no problem with the game whatsoever.

lee no permission was given, or am i on about a different game?

He is doing more than giving permission to sub in he is specifically asking him to sub in.

not at all lee....he asked if he wants to sub in, he didnt say "u can sub in" or anythin even close to those lines lol

ant- consider this sentence:
"Would you mind getting me that glass of water?"
That is asking someone to do something right? The person will then get the glass of water (carry out the action).

Now the same question:
"Would you mind subbing in?"
That is asking him to sub in. red4ever therefore went on and subbed in.

not at all seb, i could say "no i wont" or "i cant, im busy"

no permission was given, and if capt was online, why didnt the capt just make the sub, so no confusion would ever have happened?

Because either the player in the game could have played it or red4ever if he saw him...

What's the difference between those two examples? Not sure how the second does not ask him to sub in...

I wasnt online when Ryan online when ryan subbed himself in as we had family up here throughout the day or i would have done it myself and thats why i posted a few days earlier as i wasnt sure i could get online and i wasnt sure if toluca was gunna be online as he is sometimes busy during the morning(mexican time) and he probs wouldnt have been able to post the sub

yes it asks him to, it doesnt say "red u can sub urself in if u wish" or anythin close to that...it says "would u mind subbin in"

asks a question, not givin permission...complete difference

well if a capt was online y not just say "x player, y player or z player can sub in if they wish, they have permission"

I think that's what they meant?
As the name of their clan says, they're not all native English speakers (neither am I actually). I'm fairly sure when they ask someone to sub in, they want him to sub in... that's at least what I mean when I ask someone to sub in or ask someone to get me a glass of water.

whether they want him to or not, it does NOT state a player can sub themselves in if they wish...even if it was meant to be that, it clearly was not givin permission goin by what the post says...its still only a question

im sure most, if not all people aint mind readers, i could say "im not playin this game" <<< by that ud think im not playin it at all, but what i mean is "im not playin it tonight"....complete difference in what both statements mean

No confusion did happen. I can clearly see dan asking ryan to sub in and telling him the deadline so he knows when it has to be played by.
I'm totally satisfied that this substitution is valid.
I posted 'can anyone who hasn't played against shooters sub into the last game.' recently...
Some pedantic people could say that I was asking for an explanation of how subs work and i should have put 'will anyone who hasn't played against shooters sub into the last game.'
Course it's all a bit ridiculous

then a few days earlier why didnt u post "the followin players have permission to sub themselves in:......"

still askin a question, not givin permission

also by sayin "can anyone sub themselves in who hasnt played" is givin permisson, yes its a question, it it clearly states anyone who hasnt played, can sub in"...different question entirely to "can u play"

I didnt need to put player x,y,z can sub in when i asked ryan to sub in and he said yes ill play the game

so he said yes he will play?