Lol I actually went by when the tournament starts :D

Lets sack punk and then all is good

Lynch him lynch himmmmmm \o/

In all fairness the decision to have punkpoet run the killer semi final that pds are playing in wasn't the best. Should have been someone from the other 3 teams.

Agreed ^, for his sake as well as everyone elses.

Well at least it's fetched a talking point to laugh about , cos I think wi out such stuff I fear even less users will come on

Ive ran pds games before... But yeah does put me in a tough position as ive all ready been called bias and its been implied I did it for an advantage... i think most will see through that.
i am sorry for the situation and me having second thoughts then changing my mind, should of stuck to my guns.
But its done now, it was a very even game and firecly fought, which pds won, think people should be happy we got to the final after having a rough season in fcl.
Gl in the play offs, should be tight.

zantetsukenz

you stirring again lol

Lol only one person was stirring and hes gone quiet, the rest was a lively debate.

I take the responsibility for this one lads. I went off abroad and didn't leave a plan in place. It's me that can get in touch with all of our players and I just assumed we'd be fine without me. In hindsight I should've sent more messages and let Eri and Zante know what was happening. Sorry boys!!

Lol welcome to my world you will be classed as biased whatever you decide.

I was happy to support you last night whatever decision you made as I could easily have backed a case for allowing and a case for not and as you were running it I left you to decide. This is what most people who keep quoting the rules forget that there can be other factors outside of what the rules state.

Fran was online well before the start time and unfortunately had to reboot which could happen to anyone and then was late for start time, this was not frans fault or yours but you had a decision to make and you made it, it was just a pity that others had to stick their tuppence worth in.

I almost missed the game as well as it took me 15 mins to get into the game, if I had been a few minutes late would I have been upset, the answer would be yes the same as fran but at the same time as per the rules I would have accepted as it would have just been unfortunate.

As for not been able to captain a game with PDs, I have no issue with it as I trust your judgement and I know that you are not biased you are just in a position where you will be slated by some whatever you decide but that is an ongoing clan issue that we will always have.

Well done to pocket dynamos last night you deserved to win

Nice point..fair and i understand..i have spoke with poet via pm and there is no bad blood at all..it's all in the past.

But!

now i cant even be chosen for the game on the 29th... even i i was..im in hospital the next morning and il be fasting! starving..screaming for a beer etc etc and will need my sleep damn early to be fresh and make the hospital with traffic in my area!

Thanks, I can see everyone's point of view here, that's the problem with clan rules they can always be twisted and possible to view in different ways..

Can't remember or be bothered to look to see who mentioned they hope Zac wasn't running the final as I think he's said enough times that he's not interested if people have an issue and would rather take the role..

Always the same arguments where both sides have valid points in clans, we've all seen it season after season.

Just need to clarify the rules and yes make sure all details and info on the games are posted in a prior agreed forum so this doesn't reoccur ..

Sorry to steal the thread,,,,

Dont worry mate I've hijacked this thread for 24 hours

Thanks for the kind words Keith, and the others who put nice stuff :)

There isn't a argument going on, I don't think anyone is actually upset here. People seem to be overlooking the actual issues in favour of being defensive though which is rather pointless.

Once again I say the rules don't say anything about needing to be in a specific room by a certain time. Everyone who is due to play should be given a fair chance to. Using a room like NaC has drawbacks when other players enter which is feasible since it is a public room. If a room is to be used for meeting then it should be a private game room so that only the players are in there and have been sent an invite using the list provided.

Alternatively, clans reps provide a list at ten to the start time so the referee can sort the room out ready and have all pms open. At the start time if I amendments have been made to the lists those on the list get invited. Anyone who isn't in the room 3 minutes past gets left out of the next end of invites. Anyone left out would be for a fair reason having been given a chance.

If it's played like a tournament the. It shouldn't matter where you are as long as you are online to get an invite.

One of the reasons for the NOC room is simply, before id invite people and they would be in game, id then have to tell there caps to get them out of game, which wastes time.
So if they are in NOC room its easier for me, well on paper lol.

Doesn't that mean we're punishing players who aren't in the correct room over players who decide to play a game when they should be in killer?

It seems easier to me to not allow someone who was in another game at the start time than someone in another room.

FCL Golden Cue

Here are the final standings. Players must have played at least 6 matches to qualify for the Golden Cue.

Congratulations to turtle1560 for winning it!

Well done Sean

Jesus, just scrapped the 70% again this season! Pretty sure that leaves me with 70% + in the FCL for every season I've played for Uprising and the only one across the site to do it (purely for the one season where I was the only one with 70% but woo!)

Well done Sean, quality as always.

Sorry I couldn't be on Sunday for the killer. When is the date for the play-off? This Sunday?