just happened to find these 2 quotes in the untouchables capped thread, page 45, these were posted in an argument over madmiketyson playing as MMT last season

pot_the_lot
13:53 Wed 14 Oct 09 look its simple mmt is madmiketyson i was meant to change but wot with me getting a job last week i have been at work and forgot to do so i have apologised.

so result will stand and ur player needs to finish

madmiketyson
14:45 Wed 14 Oct 09 Same person dozy...

lets be honest madmiketyson was never getting changed to MMT, that doesnt matter tho, the point is he played on another account that wasnt registered and because Steph knew it was him the result stood, is there any data or proof out there to prove 100% madmiketyson is MMT, I doubt it, all hear say, I think we all know _colin is egotistical and the result should stand just like it did with MMT or madmiketyson

posted on the new forum

Hypocritical. Draconian.

Just two of the words I could use to describe this situation.

If it has happened before, why were the rules not clear in the first place to prevent this?

Thanks to Alan for providing some pertinent proof of this, I'm not going to bother with the other site for posting now. It's pointless if they can't see a cause for concern.

dear me it gets so boring, i fought after double trouble and onwards with your own clan, you guys would be treated differently. obviously not!

As has been pointed out numerous times, the case with madmiketyson vs mmt was a matter of a league host forgetting to update the web page.

The player in question fulfilled his responsibilities in terms of notifying about the account change BEFORE the first fixture the new account was ever used in. The player did not break any rules, the only issue there was a slow update by the league hosts - no more, no less.

That case has nothing in common with the issues having been discussed regarding egotistical vs. _colins

we all know madmiketyson was never getting changed to mmt, he had both accounts for long enough so why all of a sudden change it, I forgot to change it came out because someone questioned it, fact is the username MMT wasnt registered to play and Steph said the result stands lol


Edited at 03:03 Sun 15/11/09 (GMT)

How can egotistical vs _collins be anything.... THEIR THE SAME PERSON!

Simple as.

The ruling wasn't clear, hence the debate. If it happened before why wasn't it clear?

No excuse.

Why he decided to stop playing on one account and start using the other I have no idea and couldn't possibly care less about. Fact remains that Steph was informed BEFORE the fixture and that's all that matters. Nor is this even a remotely on-topic discussion here in this thread, so end of story for my part.

So why didn't the rules state this before?

If there's a previous occurance, surely it should be compensated for in the rules clearly, and not changed and defended after it is questioned.

A few times I did not play on my "officially stated name" in each situation i made it clear to the player I was the same person... so I don't get why there is so much of an issue here =/

no list - this weeks list will be the same as last week.

you can make any changes by using your substitutes

Next weeks fixture

ITZ v Sharpshooters
Fellowship v Adventure
MVP v Warriors
Blackout v TPA

Draw released shortly

Whats all that crap about ^

Adventures V Blackout

_pool_bird_ v notorius_pig

sporky_lover v pscyo05

crazzymadman v aflumpire

jerry v_pau1_

_colins v gooselfc

Come you lot get these games played before Lems head burst!

yes , i can feel me temples throbbin

FPL

Adventures V Blackout

Crazzy v Flumps

9US 3-0
8UK 3-0
8US 3-0
Straight 1-0

Overall 10-0 Good games flumps, Score doesnt represent the games played. Caught me on form

Im not playing in the FPL league as from now, sorry people

Because no rules, old or current, were violated in the mmt case, no misunderstandings or unclear aspects at all. If the player or captain had somehow not fulfilled their responsibilities as a result of misinterpreting rules, that would have been a different ballgame.

im fed up of the bickering , i accept the decision , can we move on now , its only a fluffin game

Bill & Lems Adventures vs The Fellowship

crazzymadman vs _vol_

8UK 1-4
9Ball 1-4
8US 3-2

Total 5-10

Great games Vol

In all my time on here i have to admit ive never met such a consistant great player!

Sorry team

Edited at 21:43 Sun 15/11/09 (GMT)

FBI v Bill & Lem's Adventure

_niall_ vs _pool_bird_
_marc_ vs crazzymadman
g_shot vs jerry
jgo3000 vs stiky_fingas
__matt__ vs _kgb797_
master_p00l vs turophile
revinax vs _colins
poolh8r vs _gash_


Bill & Lem's Adventure v The Fellowship

sheepshooter vs gandalf
sporky_lover vs cuester
lemsip_ vs gladul
stiky_fingas vs laranjeiro
_colins vs clintusmc
_pool_bird_ vs coolhandct
jerry vs the_rookie
crazzymadman vs _vol_

hunt them down , get them played , good luck lads n lasses , no name changes until after these fixtures please

well done crazzy , could u wait till i post fixtures before u post results please , no one likes a show off lol