Ok how mads this gunna sound..

Ruth yeah? I dont really like her singing when songs are chose for her..BUT love her wen shes in bottom 2 and belts her own out..That song was
A-MAY-ZING last night!

Daniel ~ Whats he still doing there Jeeeeeeeez!

Diana ~ Me fave to win still

JLS ~ Be in Final with Diana

Alex ~ Was FAB!

Eoghan ~ Sweet but nahhhhh

Rachel ~ Great voice but getting to bossy

Laura ~ Voice was great, she shud still be in


DIANA TO WIN....................or JLS

Agree bout rachel getty bossy miserable so n so

i agree paula , why the hell is danny still in he wont win it

i wanted daina and laura to be in the final

This woman is so determined to succeed for her kids and herself, i dont think she is being bossy, she is ruthlessly determined to do well and thats the strength of her character...forget her past and the crap she is going thyrough at the moment, but consider this.

She has a unique vocal (like Amy Whinehouse does for example)
The songs and catergories DO NOT suit her sound, she is not a good allrounder, but a First class and World Class specialist in Jazz/blues/soul....she is no way a 'pop' singer.

Danni Minogue has done as well as expected, but has not the experience to nuture the talent, Rachel took things on board and although the song she sang was painful to listen too, i feel that shes trying to steer her own destiny....good luck to her, if she does not win X- Factor then it may be to her advantage as she can then concentrate on specialising in her vocal range and genre of music....and do damn well at it too

This is ridiculous. I shall say no more

When will people realise that once you're off, you're off!


http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/entertainment/7720144.stm

They have a fair point though and quite in there right to be angry......why on earth wasnt Daniel in the bottom 2??..he is cruise cabaret at best.

However....whats done is done

when is rock week so Ruth can belt out a proper song to do her justice

*drools*

Its the PUBLIC voting remember !!!

Tids ~ I said Racheal has a great voice :S:S:S

Ruth has a great pair of lungs though

i was refering to the 'bossy' comment

Be better if she learnt to sing in tune tbh.

True....but its a double edged sword....painful as it sounded, a blind man in fog could have spotted that she was plainly uncomfortable with the song she was given, this all adds to the confusion and affects performance, like i said she could be an excellent genre specialist...not an 'all rounder'

Tids ~ Isnt being an 'all rounder' is what its all about tho?

I dont deny the fact she has a great voice at all and its clear she's determined to do well, but the fact is she's coming across too bossy!

Simon told her at the 1st boot camp not to 'ruin it for herself' cos she was mouthing off then too!!

That said....again..i think she has a great voice.





EDIT:While am here...LMAO @ Chris's post bout Ruth!

Edited at 09:54 Thu 13/11/08 (GMT)

Nothing wrong with being a good all-rounder P but the X Factor means just that....something out of the ordinary is what is really the X Factor, not someone who sounds like someone else...and to have something unique and different and know that there is a quality vocal waiting for the right genre must be frustrating...i know ive mentioned Amy Whinehouse before but she is not 'pop' she is jazz/soul suited with her vocal, and thats what Rachel is......i know she was bossy but she was brough back down to earth by Cowell and shes holding it as well as she can, shame her so called mentor is Danny, if Simon or maybe Louis had her then it wouldnt matter if she won or not, i bet any money she has a great future as shes been made public.
So i think being on the X Factor is enough for her, win or lose this competition she will be a winner in other ways and good luck to her

Edited at 15:16 Thu 13/11/08 (GMT)

No doubt about it mate.


And now, for a brief update...I think she has a great voice, and i agree with everything youve said about her..BUT.. i still think she's a tad too bossy! Lets not forget it was Danni who put her through, yet i feel Rachel is resenting her.

For all we say here, about it, Danni, Song choices, Her being bossy or not, bad press blah de blah, its all down to the public and im sure am not the only one who can see her 'attitude' and its that, that will be her downfall.


This has been Paula A, on FP Forums Thankyou for watching...and now its back to over to Chris and Ruths Lungs.


~Paula~

mmmm now there's a thought!!

she has had a hard life, nobody can blame her for being that way, the strong survive and thats what she is doing, albeit being too strong...and too determined makes her 'bossy'

*Acts all bossy*

SHUT UP BANDIT!!

Who would you like to win Sir *Smiles Sweetly*

LOL

pfff so much for the ADULT discussion.

I dont care who wins, i suspect it will be that gorgeous coloured girl who sounds similar to Leona, it would be a shame to have another like that though.....Personally i hate that little blonde bird who was sick last week, her quirky tone annoys me.


Ruth to win....crackin' pair of lungs that one....ole