I'm neither here nor there on this one. Always played Fifa when younger, probably as a result of it being commercially more successful and available. Got into Pro Evo a few years back. Only problem I had was the lack of licensed teams such as most of the Premiership teams (I'm pretty ana1 about things like that). Fifa had gotten too big for its boots and put ad campaigns at a higher priority than improving gameplay. But this year i'm playing Fifa09 on the 360. It has to be the best football game ever. It's brilliant. Haven't actually played the latest Pro Evo instalment but I heard it's nowhere near Fifa's current level.
Opinions?

You've pretty much summed up my experience of the games too there!
Always used to love fifa, converted to a pro evo fan a few years back, but I can't stand the new one.
So I'm back playing fifa on the 360, and I think it's brilliant

Has to be fifa just beacause the team names are real haha

Fifa - more realism

fifa!

Fifa 09 is the best without a doubt!

Pro evo obviously

Pro evo until recently, the new one is awful.
FIFA this year people!

i thought i saw a thread like this a while ago

pes

gotta b pro evo

fifa cause has all leuge teams in it if ur team is not in prem

fifa!

Used to be pro evo, now it's call if duty

I made that post before i got my xbox back and after trying them both out i change my mind.

fifa is more realistic with all the tranfers and player stats but i prefer pro evo game play and graphics